top of page
Victoria Services Inc, HVAC & Plumbing Logo
York Logo
Navien HVAC company logo
Rheem HVAC manufacturing logo

Tankless vs. Traditional: A Comprehensive Water Heater Comparison

Updated: Apr 25

Navien Tankless water heater vs traditional tank water heater

Tankless vs Traditional Water Heaters: Which Is Right For You?

As our demand for efficient water heating grows, the debate between tankless vs traditional water heaters gains importance.

This guide breaks down the key differences, efficiency factors, and cost benefits of each system, helping you make a smart choice for your home. Learn more about tankless water heaters here: Tankless Water Heater System Installation with MassSave Rebate Incentives in Greater Boston, MA

Key Factors for Comparison: Tankless vs Traditional

  1. Efficiency and Energy Consumption

  2. Cost Comparison

  3. Hot Water Availability

  4. Space and Installation

  5. Which is Better for Massachusetts Residents: Tankless or Traditional?

"tankless water heaters are 24% to 34% more energy-efficient than storage tank water heaters"

1. Efficiency and Energy Consumption

Tankless Water Heaters:

Traditional Tank Heaters:

  • Continuously maintain a set temperature, resulting in standby heat loss.

  • Higher energy consumption as the system works to keep stored water hot.

  • Less energy-efficient compared to tankless alternatives.

2. Cost Comparison

Tankless Water Heaters:

  • Higher upfront costs for purchase and installation.

  • Potential for long-term savings due to increased energy efficiency.

  • Lifespan of 20+ years, reducing replacement frequency.

Traditional Tank Heaters:

  • Lower upfront costs but may incur higher operating expenses.

  • Frequent replacements every 10-15 years, adding to long-term costs.

  • Prone to sediment buildup, affecting efficiency and requiring maintenance.

3. Hot Water Availability

Tankless Water Heaters:

  • Continuous hot water supply on demand.

  • No need to wait for a tank to refill, reducing water wastage.

  • Ideal for households with varying hot water needs.

Traditional Tank Heaters:

  • Limited hot water supply based on the tank's capacity.

  • Longer wait times for hot water, leading to potential wastage.

  • Susceptible to running out of hot water during peak usage.

4. Space and Installation

Tankless Water Heaters:

  • Compact and wall-mounted, saving valuable space.

  • Installation flexibility, suitable for various home sizes and layouts.

  • May require upgrades to gas lines or electrical systems.

Traditional Tank Heaters:

  • Larger footprint, occupying more floor space.

  • Installation may be restricted to specific locations.

  • Generally simpler installation process compared to tankless.

5. Which is Better for Massachusetts Residents: Tankless or Traditional?

Determining the best water heating option for Massachusetts residents depends on the homes' specific needs. However, the state does lean towards upgrading to tankless water heaters for several reasons.

  • Tankless systems align with Massachusetts' sustainability goals, such as its ambitious energy missions for 2030 and 2050, emphasizing reduced greenhouse gas emissions and increased renewable energy usage.

  • Incentives programs like Mass Save further promote sustainable choices, highlighting tankless heaters' benefits in energy efficiency, lower utility costs, and adaptability to seasonal temperature changes.

  • Although initial costs are higher, the long-term advantages in energy savings and environmental friendliness make tankless water heaters a compelling option homeowners in Massachusetts.

Tankless water heaters versus storage tank water heaters, a comparison infographic


In the tankless vs. traditional water heater debate, the choice depends on your priorities, budget, and long-term goals. While tankless systems offer unparalleled efficiency and continuous hot water, traditional tanks have their place with lower upfront costs. Consider your household's hot water needs, space constraints, and financial considerations to make an informed decision that aligns with your lifestyle.

For more information or to continue reading about water heaters, visit: Water Heater System Installation with MassSave Rebate Incentives in Greater Boston, MA

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) - Tankless Water Heater

Q: Are tankless water heaters energy-efficient in colder climates like Massachusetts?

A: Yes, tankless water heaters are designed to work efficiently in colder climates, providing hot water on-demand even during the chilliest New England winters.

Q: How do tankless water heaters save energy compared to traditional tank water heaters?

Q: Can tankless water heaters be installed in older homes, and what's the installation time?

Q: Do tankless water heaters save money on utility bills, and how long is their lifespan?

Q: Are tankless water heaters eligible for incentives through the Mass Save program?


bottom of page